My black Lab and Golden mix, Lovely, is a veeeeeeeery picky eater. She will eat cat, horse, chicken, duck, rabbit, and bird food - and people food, of course - but I have to fight her to get her to eat anything meant for dogs, even canned food! It's a struggle trying to find good, healthy treats that she will eat. I bought a small bag of the frosted bones for her, and she ate both bones, dug into the trash, pulled out the bag they came in, and begged for more! I'm ecstatic!!!! Thank you, Chews Naturally!